***CONTAINS SPOILERS***
I have finally caught this film, and it has created an inner turmoil within me that has left me unable to answer a fairly simple question: is this the greatest bit of cinematic Trek ever made, or so faithful to the original that it actually damages it?
The plot is pretty straightforward (well, as much as a story that involved the intricacies of time travel can be). In the year 2287 (which is seven years after the events of the previous film, Nemesis) there is an attempt to save the planet Romulus that goes wrong, and it ends up being destroyed. Spock was part of the team that was involved in the failure to save Romulus, and the after effects cause a black hole into the past. Spock is sucked through, ending in in 2258. A massive Romulan mining vessel tries to follow him, but ends up in 2233, where it destroys the USS Kelvin (which just happens to have Kirks parents aboard). His father dies and his mother survives to give birth to James T. Kirk in the middle if the battle.
This already varies from established Trekchronology, but I don’t mind – the timeline has been changed by the Romulans after all. So the Kirk in this film is a fatherless rebel.
The Romulan ships tries again, and this time ends up in 2258 whereby they destroy Vulcan to get back at Spock. Fine, no problems there.
Until the end of the film, of course. During it, you assume that somehow events will be restored to their original timeline. But this is the thing that upset me about the film: none of that happens. So by the end of the movie, the events within it have reshaped the whole Star Trek universe as we know it.
So, this means that none of the events in Star Trek the TV series can have happened as we saw them. So episodes set on Vulcan. Spock’s Mother (Amanda, who appears in the original episode Journey to Babel) is dead so we can never see her. Sarek dies on Vulcan in a TNG episode, but that cannot have happened either. In short, the events in this movie mean that the events in any series (apart from Enterprise) cannot have happened. That whole timeline is closed.
I would love to be able to dismiss this as a “parallel univere” but sadly I cannot, as the Spock that has existed through all of the TV shows survives into this universe. He has memories of all of the events in the original show, the movies, even the TNG episode in which he appeared (there is some great contunuity; it appears that he is still the Vulcan Ambassador to Romulus, as he was the last time we saw him). But since the universe was reshaped by the Romulans, none of that will actually happen. So bascially, in 2287, as soon as the Romulan ship travels back in time, that timeline that all of the shows that we have enjoyed ceases to exist. And I have a problem with that. To invalidate over 500 episodes of television just to “wipe the slate clean” as it were is going way too far.
If it wasn’t for this, I would have loved the movie. I have no problem with the redesign of the Enterprise,and some of the casting was spot on. Zachary Quinto was brilliant as Spock – in fact he overshadowed Chris Pine (Kirk) in the same way that Nimoy did Shatner all those years ago. Like Shatner, there is nothing essentially wrong with Pine’s performance, but Quinto was awesome as the young Spock.
But, music, effects and performances aside, I cannot forgive the fact that they have destroyed all that has come before. And, because of the way it was done, I cannot ignore it either. I know this makes me a sad fan who ought to “get a life” as Shatner once said, but to sweep away the previous shows to tell this story was unforgivable, and for me utterly spoilt the film. It looks like there is going to be a sequel. Fine, you watch it. I don’t want to.